In this article
  1. How the Tomatometer works
  2. Why 60% isn't 6/10
  3. What Certified Fresh means
  4. The audience score: the Popcornmeter
  5. How IMDb is different
  6. How to read the scores together
  7. Frequently asked questions

You check Rotten Tomatoes before choosing a film. One shows 95%, another 62%. It is natural to read those as marks out of 100, as if the first film is excellent and the second is mediocre. That is not what the numbers mean.

Here is how the scores are actually calculated, and how to read them properly.

Key facts

  • The Tomatometer is the percentage of critic reviews that are positive, not an average score.
  • Fresh means at least 60% of reviews are positive; below that it is Rotten.
  • Certified Fresh needs 75% or more, plus a minimum number of reviews.
  • IMDb uses a weighted average of user ratings from 1 to 10.

How the Tomatometer works

According to Rotten Tomatoes, the Tomatometer score is the percentage of professional critic reviews that are positive. Each review from an approved critic is counted as either Fresh (positive) or Rotten (negative). The site then reports what share of reviews are Fresh.

When at least 60% of reviews are positive, the film gets a red tomato and is called Fresh. Below 60%, it gets a green splat and is Rotten.

Why 60% isn’t 6/10

Because each review is reduced to a simple yes or no, the Tomatometer tells you how many critics liked a film, not how much they liked it. Consider three made-up films, each reviewed by ten critics:

FilmWhat critics gave itTomatometerAverage mark
Film AAll ten give 6/10 and call it decent100%6.0/10
Film BSeven give 9/10, three give 3/1070%7.2/10
Film CFive give 10/10, five give 4/1050%7.0/10
Simplified illustration. We assume a 6/10 counts as a positive review; in reality, each critic’s verdict is recorded as Fresh or Rotten.

Film A scores a perfect 100% but nobody loved it. Film C is Rotten at 50% even though half the critics thought it was a masterpiece. A high Tomatometer means a film is widely acceptable. It does not guarantee that it is great.

What Certified Fresh means

Certified Fresh is a stricter badge. Rotten Tomatoes says a film needs:

  • A Tomatometer of 75% or higher.
  • At least five reviews from Top Critics, a group of more established reviewers.
  • At least 80 reviews for a wide release, or 40 for a limited release or a streaming film.

TV seasons need reviews from at least 20 critics, five of them Top Critics.

The audience score: the Popcornmeter

Next to the tomato you will see a popcorn bucket. The Popcornmeter shows the percentage of audience members who rated a film 3.5 stars or higher out of 5. A full bucket means at least 60% did; a tipped-over bucket means fewer did.

Where Rotten Tomatoes can confirm that people bought a ticket, it shows a score based on these Verified Ratings by default. A film earns the Verified Hot badge with a verified audience score of 90% or more, from at least 500 verified ratings for a wide release or 250 for a limited one.

How IMDb is different

IMDb works differently. Registered users rate titles from 1 to 10. According to IMDb, the rating on a title page is a weighted average, not a simple mean. IMDb does not publish the exact weighting, but says it is designed to reduce the effect of unusual voting. To enter the Top 250 Movies chart, a film currently needs at least 25,000 ratings, and only votes from regular IMDb users count.

IMDb title pages also show the Metascore from Metacritic, which works the opposite way to the Tomatometer. Metacritic assigns a score to each critic’s review and then takes a weighted average, so it captures how much critics liked a film, not just how many.

ScoreWho ratesWhat it measures
TomatometerApproved criticsShare of reviews that are positive
MetascoreSelected criticsWeighted average of scores given to reviews
PopcornmeterAudience membersShare rating 3.5 stars or more
IMDb ratingRegistered usersWeighted average of 1 to 10 ratings
Four common film scores, side by side.

How to read the scores together

  1. A high Tomatometer with a modest average usually means a solid, safe film rather than a classic.
  2. A middling Tomatometer can hide a divisive film that some people adore. Read a few reviews.
  3. A big gap between critics and audiences is a clue about who the film was made for.
  4. Check the number of reviews. A 100% from 12 critics is less reliable than 92% from 300.

Scores can also be manipulated. See our guide to spotting fake and paid movie reviews, and our tips on reading polls without being misled, since the same logic applies to any percentage.

Frequently asked questions

Does 90% on Rotten Tomatoes mean 9/10?

No. It means 90% of counted critic reviews were positive. The critics’ actual marks could be much lower.

What does Fresh mean on Rotten Tomatoes?

A film is Fresh when at least 60% of critic reviews are positive, and Rotten when fewer than 60% are.

How do you get Certified Fresh?

A Tomatometer of at least 75%, five or more Top Critic reviews and a minimum number of reviews, such as 80 for a wide release.

Is IMDb’s rating a simple average?

No. IMDb uses a weighted average of user ratings, designed to reduce the effect of unusual voting.

Browse more in our Movies section.

Sources

  1. Rotten Tomatoes: About the Tomatometer, Popcornmeter and Certified Fresh
  2. IMDb Help: Ratings FAQ
  3. Metacritic: How we create the Metascore