In this article
Every year brings more remakes. Studios like them because audiences already know the story and the title. But does a famous name actually guarantee a hit?
We looked up 11 well-known remakes released between 2012 and 2019 on Box Office Mojo, a box office database owned by IMDb. For each, we compared worldwide ticket sales with the reported production budget, and with what the original film took.
Key facts
- Disney’s animated-to-live-action remakes in our sample all grossed $350 million or more worldwide.
- The Lion King (2019) took about $1.66 billion, 6.4 times its $260 million budget.
- The best ratio was A Star Is Born (2018): about $440 million on a $36 million budget.
- Ben-Hur (2016) grossed about $94 million on a $100 million budget.
The results
| Remake | Budget | Worldwide gross | Gross ÷ budget | Original’s gross |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Beauty and the Beast (2017) | $160m | $1,266m | 7.9× | $451m (1991) |
| The Lion King (2019) | $260m | $1,662m | 6.4× | $979m (1994) |
| Aladdin (2019) | $183m | $1,054m | 5.8× | $504m (1992) |
| The Jungle Book (2016) | $175m | $968m | 5.5× | $206m (1967) |
| A Star Is Born (2018) | $36m | $440m | 12.2× | $80m (1976, US only) |
| Dumbo (2019) | $170m | $353m | 2.1× | n/a |
| RoboCop (2014) | $100m | $243m | 2.4× | $53m (1987) |
| Ghostbusters (2016) | $144m | $229m | 1.6× | $297m (1984) |
| Total Recall (2012) | $125m | $198m | 1.6× | $261m (1990) |
| Point Break (2015) | $105m | $134m | 1.3× | $84m (1991) |
| Ben-Hur (2016) | $100m | $94m | 0.9× | $74m (1959) |
What the numbers show
1. Disney’s remakes were in a league of their own
Beauty and the Beast, The Lion King, Aladdin and The Jungle Book all grossed between about five and eight times their budgets, and all beat the originals’ totals by a wide margin. These were remakes of family films that parents had loved as children and could now share with their own kids.
2. Action and sci-fi remakes mostly struggled
RoboCop, Ghostbusters, Total Recall, Point Break and Ben-Hur all grossed less than 2.5 times their budgets. Ghostbusters and Total Recall took less than the originals, even before allowing for decades of inflation.
3. Small budgets can win big
A Star Is Born, the fourth screen version of the story, cost a fraction of the Disney films. Its gross was more than 12 times its budget, the best ratio in our sample.
Why gross ÷ budget is only a rough guide
Box office gross is the money taken at cinemas, not what the studio keeps. Cinemas keep a share of every ticket. Published budgets also usually leave out marketing, which can be very large for a big release. So a film needs to gross well above its budget just to break even, and a ratio below about 2× is often a warning sign.
On the other hand, cinemas are not the only income. Films also earn from streaming, TV and home sales. A remake that disappoints in cinemas can still make money over time.
Inflation changes the comparison
All the figures above are in money of the day. Ben-Hur’s $74 million in 1959 was worth far more than $74 million today, so the 2016 remake’s slightly higher gross does not mean it was more successful. The same applies to the 1967 Jungle Book and the 1987 RoboCop.
So do remakes make money?
Some do, spectacularly. But a famous title alone is not enough. In our sample, the remakes that worked had a loyal family audience or a fresh take with a modest budget. Those that leaned on a big budget and a well-known name without a strong new reason to watch often barely covered their costs.
Before trusting the buzz around any new release, see how Rotten Tomatoes scores are really calculated, and our guide to spotting fake and paid reviews.
Frequently asked questions
What is the highest-grossing remake?
Of the films we checked, The Lion King (2019) grossed the most, about $1.66 billion worldwide according to Box Office Mojo.
Do remakes usually beat the original?
In nominal dollars, most remakes in our sample out-grossed the originals, but ticket prices and inflation make that comparison unfair to older films.
Why does Hollywood make so many remakes?
Known titles reduce marketing risk, because audiences already recognise the story. The data shows this works best for beloved family films.
How much does a film need to make to break even?
There is no fixed rule, but because cinemas keep part of ticket sales and marketing costs are extra, a film generally needs to gross well above its production budget.
Browse more in our Movies section.



