In this article
  1. Our backtest: are candlestick patterns reliable on the S&P 500?
  2. What the results mean
  3. What academic research says
  4. How to use candlesticks sensibly
  5. Frequently asked questions

Are candlestick patterns reliable? On their own, not very. We tested five of the most popular patterns on every trading day of the SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) from January 2000 to October 2026. None of them predicted the next week’s move better than picking a random day, by any margin that could not be explained by chance. Academic studies on US stocks mostly agree, though a few find value in specific patterns.

Key facts

  • 6,726 trading days of SPY tested, from 3 January 2000 to 22 October 2026.
  • 57.3%: share of all days followed by a higher price five trading days later.
  • 44.6%: same figure after a bullish engulfing pattern, worse than a random day.
  • 0 of 5 patterns beat a random day with statistical significance.

Our backtest: are candlestick patterns reliable on the S&P 500?

We downloaded SPY’s daily open, high, low and close prices (the same data shown on Yahoo Finance) and coded five classic patterns. For reversal patterns, we required the trend they are supposed to reverse: a lower close than five days earlier for bullish patterns, and a higher one for bearish patterns. We then measured the price change from the pattern’s close to the close 5 and 10 trading days later.

PatternSignalsAvg 5-day moveUp after 5 daysAvg 10-day moveUp after 10 daysBetter than random?
All days (baseline)6,726+0.16%57.3%+0.31%59.9%–
Bullish engulfing101−0.26%44.6%−0.10%51.5%No (t = −1.41)
Hammer90−0.35%58.9%−0.36%57.8%No (t = −1.32)
Bearish engulfing157+0.29%54.8%+0.40%65.0%No (t = 0.89)
Shooting star53−0.16%49.1%−0.03%54.7%No (t = −0.87)
Doji675+0.18%57.8%+0.43%64.6%No (t = 0.33)
World Elev backtest of SPY daily prices, 3 Jan 2000 to 22 Oct 2026. Close-to-close changes, excluding dividends and trading costs. t compares each pattern’s average 5-day move with the baseline; values beyond about ±2 would suggest a real effect.

What the results mean

  • The bullish signals pointed the wrong way. After bullish engulfing patterns and hammers, SPY was on average lower five days later, the opposite of what the patterns promise, though not by enough to be significant either.
  • The bearish signals did not work either. After a bearish engulfing pattern, SPY was higher 65% of the time ten days later, more often than on a random day.
  • Small samples mislead. With only 53 to 157 signals per pattern over 26 years, a few lucky or unlucky weeks swing the averages. That is why many chart guides quote success rates that do not hold up.
  • The market’s upward drift dominates. SPY rose over 57% of all five-day periods, so any pattern that says “sell” starts at a disadvantage.

What academic research says

Ben Marshall, Martin Young and Lawrence Rose tested candlestick strategies on US stocks in a paper published in the Journal of Banking & Finance in 2006. The thesis behind it, available from Massey University, used a bootstrap method that generates random price series and concluded that “candlestick technical analysis does not have value” for the stocks studied, finding no evidence that a candlestick trader would beat the market.

Not every study agrees. Tsung-Hsun Lu and Yung-Ming Shiu tested every possible one-day pattern on the 30 Dow Jones stocks from 1974 to 2009 and reported in Applied Economics (2016) that several patterns may be profitable, with predictive power rising after 1992. Results depend on the market, period, pattern definitions and costs.

How to use candlesticks sensibly

  • Treat a pattern as a description of one day’s trading, not a forecast.
  • Never trade a pattern without a stop-loss and a position size you can afford to lose.
  • Test any rule on years of data, including costs, before risking money.
  • Be wary of quoted success rates without the number of signals, the period and the definition used.

Learn the basics of reading prices in how to read a stock quote, and see why index construction matters in the Dow vs the S&P 500. The SEC’s Investor.gov warns that day trading is extremely risky and can lead to substantial losses quickly.

Please note: This article is for education only and is not financial advice. Past performance does not predict future results.

Frequently asked questions

Are candlestick patterns reliable?

Not on their own. In our 26-year SPY backtest, no popular pattern beat a random day with statistical significance, and most academic tests on large US stocks reach similar conclusions.

What is the most reliable candlestick pattern?

No pattern reliably predicted SPY’s next week in our test. Claims about the “most reliable” pattern usually depend on a specific market, period and definition.

Are candlestick patterns accurate?

They accurately show what happened during a trading period. As forecasts, they are weak; their success rates in our test were at or below a random day’s.

What is the success rate of a hammer candlestick?

In our SPY test, the price was higher five days after a hammer 58.9% of the time, against 57.3% for all days, but the average move was negative.

Read more in our Trading Basics section.

Sources

  1. Yahoo Finance: SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) historical prices
  2. Marshall, Young and Rose (2006), Candlestick technical trading strategies: Can they create value for investors?, Journal of Banking & Finance (RePEc)
  3. Marshall (2005), PhD thesis, Massey University
  4. Lu and Shiu (2016), Can 1-day candlestick patterns be profitable on the 30 component stocks of the DJIA?, Applied Economics (RePEc)
  5. Investor.gov (SEC): Day trading